Blog

Let’s talk about pricing — aka the fastest way to turn “we’re so busy!” into “why aren’t we making money?”

If you’re a wholesaler or manufacturer and it feels like you’re running nonstop but profits still look… meh… you might not have a work ethic problem. You might have a pricing problem.

And yes, we’re going to say the quiet part out loud: a lot of businesses are accidentally donating margin to their customers. Nice? Sure. Sustainable? Not even a little.

So let’s walk through how to spot underpricing (without needing a finance PhD), and what to do instead.

The Hidden Cost of Cost-Plus Pricing

Cost-plus is the pricing equivalent of using MapQuest in 2025. It technically works, but it’s not helping you win.

Here’s the formula we see all the time:

Cost to make/buy the product + a fixed markup = selling price

Simple? Yep.
Profit-maximizing? Nope.

Because cost-plus ignores two huge things:

1. Market demand and competition

If customers would happily pay more because your lead times are faster, your quality is better, or your service is smoother…cost-plus basically says:

“Cool. Let’s not charge for any of that.”

You’re giving away value like it’s Halloween candy.

2. Customer Perceived Value (CPV)

Your product’s value isn’t what it costs you to make. It’s what it saves them in time, risk, labor, rework, or lost sales.

If your part solves a $500,000 headache for a customer, but you’re pricing it based on plastic + labor + 10%… that’s not pricing. That’s charity in steel-toe boots.

3 Signs you’re underpricing (aka leaving money on the table)

1. Your sales conversion rate is too high

If you’re winning 90%+ of the bids you submit… that’s not always a flex. Sometimes it just means you’re the easiest “yes” in the pile.

Here’s a fun and slightly painful test:
If your customer doesn’t flinch, negotiate, or even ask a question about price…
you probably left enough margin on the table to fund their whole company picnic.

A healthy win rate should feel like:

• “We win a lot.”
• “We lost some.”
• “We negotiate often.”
  Not:
• “They accept everything instantly like they found money on the couch.”

2. You charge the same margin for everything

Do you price a standard bulk order the same way you price:

• rush jobs
• custom kitting or assembly
• weird fulfillment requirements
• multiple ship-tos
• Friday at 4pm emergencies?

Because if you do… your pricing is lying to you.

Manufacturer example:
A rush order forces overtime and weekend work, but your price only covers Monday-Friday costs. Congrats – you just subsidized their panic.

Wholesale example:
A small customer needs three drop-ship locations and special packaging. Their cost-to-serve is way higher, but your standard markup makes the big easy customer pay for the small demanding one. Your pricing should reflect how expensive it is to deliver sanity.

3. You don’t raise prices when capacity is tight

If your line is near max capacity, or inventory is flying off shelves… the market is literally screaming:

“Your product is more valuable right now.”

If demand is high and supply is tight, keeping the same price is like renting beachfront property for 1998 rates.

When you’re full, the price to get in line should reflect it.

Your path to profit-driven pricing (without making it complicated)

You don’t need to suddenly become a pricing scientist. You just need to evolve past cost-plus and into value-based thinking.

Here’s how:

1. Know your true Cost-to-Serve (CTS)

This is where Activity-Based Costing (ABC) saves your bacon.

ABC doesn’t just track materials and labor. It assigns real overhead and effort where it belongs:

• admin time
• customer service intensity
• shipping complexity
• returns/rework
• special handling
• machine setup hours
• utilities + maintenance

Example:
That low-volume customer who calls daily and needs invoice revisions? High CTS.

That big customer who orders once a year through automated EDI? Low CTS.

Same markup for both = your profit math is wearing clown shoes.

2. Introduce tiers and premium options

Right now you might be offering one price that tries to make everyone happy.
Which usually means it makes your margins unhappy.

Instead, build a tiered structure:

• standard pricing for bulk/low-maintenance business
• premium pricing for speed, customization, complexity, or low-volume high-touch orders

This lets you capture higher margins from customers who value convenience and urgency — without scaring away your volume buyers.

Different customers have different willingness to pay. Your pricing should reflect that reality.

3. Do regular price audits

Pricing isn’t “set it and forget it.” It’s “set it and check it before inflation eats your profit like a hungry accountant eats free donuts.”

We recommend quarterly Price-Volume-Mix (PVM) reviews so you can see:

• Are margins shrinking because of price?
• Volume changes?
• Product mix shifting?
• Hidden cost creep?

You’d be shocked how much profit is lost quietly over a year just because prices never got revisited.

Ready to Stop Donating Margin and Start Making Profit?

If you suspect your Cost-to-Serve (CTS) is a disaster hiding in plain sight, or if you’re still relying on MapQuest-era pricing strategies, we can help.

Our newsletter delivers advanced strategies for Activity-Based Costing (ABC), profit-driven pricing models, and operational efficiency – specifically tailored for wholesalers and manufacturers.

Stop funding your customers’ picnic and start funding your future. Subscribe now!